Wednesday, October 08, 2008
From the Mailbag: Oy, Canada!
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Oy Canada: Doc's Bailing, NICU's Missing
Even as we rush towards a similar model, it may be instructive to see how well nationalized health care's actually working out for our Neighbors to the North©. While in Chicago earlier this week (for our daughter's college orientation), my wife and I overheard a Quebecois gentleman, in the Windy City on business, telling his associates about health care, Canadian style. I was able to take some notes, which I'll share with you.
When asked about Canadian health care, he responded "when you can get it, it's pretty good." He went on to say that "if you can afford it, the best doctors are available." I didn't quite understand this at the time, since Canadian health care is, after all, "free." As you'll see in a moment, this isn't really true.
He followed up by observing that you "take what you get;" again leaving me puzzled: haven't we been told, ad nauseum, that health care is readily available Up North? And again, I later learned the bitter truth.
In his very next breath, he admitted that "care in Canada is not as good as what you get in the US." I should point out that he said he was from a city "100 kilometers from Quebec."
So what, exactly, is the truth here? Is he simply a dissatisfied Canuck, or does his opinion reflect reality?
You be the judge.
Is quality health care truly available in Canada? Well, it depends on where in Canada you live. The gummint-run health system is administered at the provincial level (as ours is regulated, for the most part, at the state level), so quality and accessibility of care can vary greatly. While critics of our system point to Canada as a role model, perhaps the tragedy of little Ava Stinson can serve as a useful rebuttal:
Turns out, there were no (as in: zero, nada, zilch) Neonatal Intensive Care Units available in the whole of Quebec.
Not. A. One.
So of course, they headed south (as have so many others before them), in order to save their baby's life. Thankfully, medics at Buffalo's (mmm, wings!) St. Joseph's Hospital will apparently be able to help, thanks to American medical technology and care. In fact, a (very) quick Google search revealed four NICU facilities in Buffalo alone.
Would it be presumptuous to ask the national health care proponents why they hate Canadians?
But certainly good quality care is available to all?
Not so much:
As we've repeatedly pointed out, one of the problems with our own national health care system, aka Medicare, is that there are a lot of doc's who shun MC patients, and the concomitant reduced reimbursement rates. Looks like that particular virus has spread North; more and more Canadian physicians are opting out of the government-run system and (back?) into private pay, private practice. That was apparently what our Quebecois businessman meant.
Does this all sound familiar?
It should: the Canadian government does, indeed, spend less on health care for its citizens, proving the old adage about getting what one pays for.
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Oy Canada: Insurance Insurance
Of course, such a plan would be a waste of money for our Friends to the North©, right? After all, they already have free health care, and lots of it.
Or maybe not:
"A group in British Columbia has offered medical waiting-list insurance to members whose government treatment is on hold."
Yup. Although we've detailed Canada's major shortage of actual health care over the years, even we hadn't quite grasped just how little is actually readily available to the average Canuck. Much as our AAA offers roadside assistance to stranded motorists, the British Columbia Automobile Association wanted to offer its members bedside assistance to those stranded on the side of the rocky Canadian health care road.
Folks who bought the policy and subsequently endured a 45 day wait for a covered expense were guaranteed access to a private clinic in BC, or even in the good ol' U S of A.
Or would have been:
"The program, which took two years to develop, never got beyond the pilot phase ... The association shut it down when critics howled and government officials checked to see if such a program was actually legal in Canada."
"Actually legal in Canada." If that doesn't send Arctic chills down your spine, then you're not paying attention: it is apparently illegal in Canada to actually try to help oneself gain access to health care. Yet that's exactly the kind of system that many proponents of a nationalized health care system want to impose on us.
Tell me again why that's a "good thing?"
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Oy Canada?
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
Oy Canada: Yer Outta Here! Edition
Friday, July 20, 2018
Oy, Canada - Part 7,285
"Patients also experience significant waiting times for various diagnostic technologies."
And that's just to be seen and treated. But what happens next? Often, the provider prescribes a med (or meds) to help treat the issue.
That's the easy part:
That's right: in at least one province CanuckCare© doesn't cover oral cancer treatment.I'm Canadian. I have universal healthcare. My oncologist prescribed Xeloda, an oral chemotherapy, to try to extend my life. In Ontario, oral chemotherapy isn't covered.— Katie Davidson (@LovlyKatieLumps) July 19, 2018
My insurance has been dragging their heels and just today declined coverage. #ThisDoesntSeemUniversal
And if one follows the comments, one is reminded of this dirty little CanuckCare© secret:
"[P]rivate insurance is responsible for oral chemo (different from province to province"
That's right, our Neighbors to the North© recognize the devastating limitations of "free" health care, and have developed (and market) supplements, much like our own government-run health care system (Medicare).
The more you know....
Thursday, September 15, 2016
Oy, Canada (Part 2,740)
"Average wait time for MRI in Canada is 101 days. I got one the next business day."
Coming here soon (the 101 day wait, that is).
Friday, October 12, 2007
Oy Canada (Part ??)
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
Yay Canada!
"The Fraser Institute is hosting a new Student Video Contest and students are eligible to win $10,000 in cash and electronics prizes. The topic is: Incentives Matter - Fixing Health Care in Canada."
According to email I received today from Director of Student Programs Vanessa Schneider, students who submit a short concept paper by the end of September (and post their videos by the end of October) are eligible to compete for the cash (no word yet on whether that's Canadian or real money). For details, click here.
Friday, June 10, 2005
Oy, Canada!
Thursday, November 29, 2018
Oy Canada: Make mine a double
"Family frustrated with lack of bed at Halifax hospital for mother with cancer"
One of the major problems with nationalized health care schemes is that the law of supply and demand is immutable. That is, there will always be a (growing) demand for health care, but there is also a limited (or at least finite) supply. We've seen what happens when you make health care a "right," and it's not pretty:
"Vowing to maintain public dental services in the province, Quebec’s health minister said Thursday he would sign a ministerial decree to block dentists from withdrawing from the public health system." The case at hand, though, is far more serious, since it involves a potentially life-threatening condition, and the patient suffering even more damage as a direct result of the system.
But then, these systems are also capable of turning out world class meds, which brings us to...
Chaser (via Ace of Spades):
"It is one of this country's great scientific achievements. The first drug ever approved that can fix a faulty gene ... But most Canadians have never heard of it."
Yup, that's right: Canadian researchers at the prestigious University of British Columbia "spent decades developing the treatment for people born with a genetic mutation that causes lipoprotein lipase disorder."
Decades, and tonnes of
The condition, more commonly known as LPLD, is the result of a genetic mutation, and causes ones blood to thicken with potentially deadly results. It also renders females who suffer from it barren (due to the high risk of miscarriage).
The med, called Glybera, promises to fix all that. The problem is that it was just too expensive, and thus was allowed to whither away on the vine.
To be fair, this isn't the fault of Canada's health care system, but one of simple economics:
"Van Deventer says the company never considered lowering the price ... Why would we? Pricing shouldn't be a political decision. It should be a rational decision based on merits and values.'
Which is contra what a lot of folks here say about "Big Pharma."
Interesting dilemma, no?
Bonus:
Canadian Hospital Urgent Care Waiting Room To Patients: Kill Yourself https://t.co/Q9lwPzlPVS from The Political Hat Blog— Political Hat Blog (@PoliticHatBlog) November 27, 2018
Tuesday, August 12, 2008
Oy Canada, Part #786 (more or less)
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Oy, Canada (Again!)
"Inside Sylvia de Vries lurked an enormous tumour and fluid totalling 18 kilograms [almost 40 pounds!]. But not even that massive weight gain and a diagnosis of ovarian cancer could assure her timely treatment in Canada."
So she did what an increasing number of ailing Canucks are doing, and headed for the border: Pontiac, Michigan. There, she had the foot-long tumor removed by a skilled American surgeon, and just in the nick of time: a few more weeks, and she faced the failure of multiple organs. Yikes!
But it gets worse: because she didn't cross all the t's and dot all the i's, the Ontario Health Insurance Plan refuses to cough up the $60 grand to cover the potentially life-saving procedure. The result is that her life savings are now depleted, and she faces huge medical bills and further treatment.
But hey, it's free!
Right?
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Oy Canada: Dog Pound Edition
Friday, September 04, 2009
Feeling sick? Feel lucky?
But remember, Canadian health care is free!
Friday, July 06, 2012
And speaking of waiting: Oy, Canada!
Says whom?
Says the folks who actually market "wait list" insurance to our Neighbors to the North. And they should know, since they actually live it, literally putting their money where their mouth is.
But wait, health insurance in Canada is free!
Indeed, and worth every penny (or is that loonie?).
The truth is, some lucky Canadians can skip the lines and head for the border; those left behind face often excruciatingly long wait times for treatment. Which is where the clever folks at Acure [ed: get it? "A cure"] come in:
"Medical Access Insurance provides Canadians with expedited access to specialist consultation, diagnostics and surgery for over 135 treatments and conditions. Medical treatment for covered conditions will be provided in weeks – not months or years."
One wonders about franchise opportunities as ObamaTax comes to fruition.
Tuesday, December 29, 2015
Oy Canada! (Part 2,739)
On the one hand, this is pretty scary; after all, it's what will happen under the IPAB. On the other, at least one knows the score, and can (try to) plan accordingly.
On the gripping hand:
"Canadian Medical Association considering allowing doctors to LIE about patients death to cover up euthanasia."
Wait, what?!
Oh, it gets worse:
The Quebec Medical College is already doing this:
"The physician must write as the immediate cause of death the disease or morbid condition which justified [the medical aid in dying] and caused the death. It is not a question of the manner of death (cardiac arrest), but of the disease, accident or complication that led to the death."
So if one has cancer, or some other fatal disease, and one is euthanized (perhaps under government orders) the cause of death won't be listed as the lethal injection, but the cancer itself.
"The deceased died of a sudden and severe influx of electrons."
Sure, go with that.
[Hat Tip: The Political Hat]
Friday, July 11, 2008
Oy Canada (Again)!
While policy wonks and candidates talk about the idea of government run, free health care, very few (I daresay none) actually address the reality of such systems. And while we see Canadian politicos eschewing the free health care to which they're entitled, and traveling thousands of miles inside the good ol' USA for actual care, I haven't read any stories lately (or, indeed, ever) about folks flying out of Washington National en route to Vancouver for that extra special medical attention.
[Hat Tip to BigGovHealth]